What It Costs to Paint a Colonial in Franklin Lakes
Pull up to a center-hall colonial in Franklin Lakes and the first thing you notice is how much house there is. Two full stories, a brick front or clapboard all around, white columns by the door, a garage wing off to one side, and a driveway long enough that you park and walk. That's the whole story behind the cost to paint a colonial in Franklin Lakes: the house is bigger than the one in the national cost guides, the trim package is bigger, and the lot gives the crew room to work — which helps, until the shade trees start growing green stuff on the north side.
We paint plenty of these houses. Franklin Lakes sits about as far from a Hoboken railroad apartment as you can get and still be in Bergen County, and the pricing works differently up there. This is the straight version: what the exterior runs, what the interior runs, where the money actually goes, and what pushes the number up or down.
The Short Answer: The Cost to Paint a Colonial in Franklin Lakes
A full exterior repaint on a typical Franklin Lakes colonial — call it a 2,800-square-foot, two-story center-hall — lands somewhere around $9,000 to $16,000 as a planning figure, trim and front door included. A whole-house interior repaint on the same house runs roughly $13,400 to $25,300. Those are wide ranges, and they're wide for a reason. The condition of the existing paint, the siding material, and how much trim the house carries can swing either job by thousands.
The national guides give you the floor. Published 2026 figures put a standard exterior repaint at roughly $1.50 to $5.00 per square foot of paintable surface, or about $3,000 to $10,000 for a typical 2,000-square-foot home, with labor running 70 to 90 percent of the total. This Old House lands at $2.20 to $4.40 a square foot and puts a two-story, 2,000-square-foot house at $6,900 to $12,700. Angi's 2026 national average is $3,178. Homewyse's May 2026 calculator starts the national average at $2.20 to $4.37 a square foot. Our statewide cost guide puts New Jersey exteriors at $1,900 to $6,900, with two-story homes at $7,000 to $12,000 — and the Northeast runs 20 to 25 percent above the national average on painter labor, at $60 to $85 an hour.
None of those numbers describe a Franklin Lakes colonial exactly. The house is bigger, the trim is heavier, and the standard of finish is higher. That's the gap this post closes.
What a Franklin Lakes Colonial Looks Like to a Painter
First, the town itself. Franklin Lakes is a borough of about 11,000 people spread across 9.41 square miles of land, and the Census Bureau puts the median value of an owner-occupied home there at $1,264,000. The September 2026 market report has the median sale at $1,525,000, with a year-to-date median of $1,780,000 across 92 closings. So the houses we're talking about are real money, and the owners tend to treat the paint job the same way they treat the roof — something you do properly, once, and then don't think about for a decade.
The lots are the first thing that changes the job. Back in 1953 the borough upgraded most of its zoning to one- and two-acre minimum lots, a fight that went all the way to the New Jersey Supreme Court in 1958. The current code still carries it: the A-130 zone wants 130,000 square feet — about three acres — where there's no public sewer or water, and 80,000 square feet where there is. The A-40 zone is 40,000 square feet, just under an acre. What that means on a Tuesday morning is room. Room to stage a lift, room to set ladders without blocking the street, room to wash and spray without the neighbor's car in the overspray zone. In Hoboken we measure access in inches. In Franklin Lakes we measure it in acres, and it shows in the price.
The house itself is the second thing. A center-hall colonial is a box with a center door, five windows across the front, and a roofline that puts the second-floor walls a long way off the ground. The typical mix we see: brick on the front, clapboard or cedar on the sides and back, or all clapboard with a brick chimney or two. Columns at the entry, shutters on most windows, a front door with sidelights, dentil molding or a frieze board under the eaves. Every one of those details is brushwork. Rollers don't do columns. Sprayers don't do shutters without a lot of masking first.
And then there's the shade. Those big lots come with mature trees, and mature trees mean the north and east faces of the house spend half the day in shade. Shade plus Bergen County humidity means mildew, and mildew means the siding on that side is green by July if nobody washed it. We see it on almost every Franklin Lakes exterior we quote. It's not a disaster — a soft wash with a mildewcide handles it — but it's prep, and prep is where the money goes.
Where the Money Goes on a Franklin Lakes Exterior
Labor is 70 to 90 percent of every exterior job. The paint is the cheap part. That's the single most useful thing to know before you read any quote, because it tells you where a cheap bid is cutting: it's cutting labor, which means it's cutting prep.
Prep alone is 40 to 60 percent of the labor cost on an exterior. On a Franklin Lakes colonial that looks like this: a full wash of every surface, scraping and sanding anywhere the old paint is failing, caulking the gaps at the trim and around every window, spot-priming the bare wood, and a mildew treatment on the shaded faces. Homewyse's baseline assumes basic prep of up to two hours per 350 square feet — and on a house with peeling paint on the south face and mildew on the north, the real number runs past that fast.
Then the siding itself. Two coats, rolled and brushed or sprayed and back-brushed, depending on the surface. Cedar drinks paint; clapboard takes it cleanly; brick takes 25 to 50 percent more product than a smooth surface because of the mortar joints. A brick-front colonial with clapboard sides is two different jobs on one house, and a quote that prices it as one surface is a quote that missed something.
Then the trim package, and on a colonial this is where the invoice grows teeth. Columns, shutters, the front door and its sidelights, the frieze board, the corner boards, the window casings — all of it hand-painted, most of it in a different sheen than the siding. Homewyse prices trim as an extra, and it's right to. On a house this size the trim can be a third of the job.
Then the paint and materials. A hundred-percent acrylic exterior runs $45 to $85 a gallon in 2026, and a house this size takes a lot of gallons. Benjamin Moore's Aura Exterior covers 250 to 350 square feet a gallon in flat and low lustre, 350 to 450 in semi-gloss, and wants 35 to 100 degrees to apply. Sherwin-Williams Duration covers 250 to 300 a gallon and goes down to 35 degrees. At those coverage rates a big colonial eats 25 to 40 gallons of siding paint before you count a single gallon of trim enamel. The difference between the cheap gallon and the good gallon on a job this size is a few hundred dollars. The difference in how long the job lasts is years.
Then access. Two stories means 32- and 40-foot ladders, and on a colonial with a garage wing or a steep grade on one side, it can mean a lift. A lift rental is a line item, not a rounding error, and so is the crew time spent moving ladders around a house with this much wall.
A real quote itemizes all of it: wash, scrape, sand, caulk, carpentry, spot prime, siding, trim, doors, shutters — each on its own line. If a quote just says "paint house: $X," it isn't a quote. It's a guess.
The Math on a Typical 2,800-Square-Foot Colonial
Here's the arithmetic, so you can check any number you're given against it. A 2,000-square-foot home has roughly 1,700 square feet of paintable surface once you count gables, trim, and soffits. Scale that to a 2,800-square-foot colonial and you're looking at about 2,400 square feet of paintable wall.
At This Old House's $2.20 to $4.40 a square foot, the siding alone on that house is roughly $5,300 to $10,600. Our statewide guide's two-story range of $7,000 to $12,000 sits right in the middle of that, which is about what you'd expect — New Jersey labor runs higher than the national average, and a colonial runs higher than a ranch.
But siding alone isn't the job. Add the full trim package — columns, shutters, door, sidelights, frieze, casings — plus the wash, the mildew treatment, and the heavy prep a ten-year-old paint job usually needs, and the honest planning figure for a full exterior on a typical Franklin Lakes colonial is more like $9,000 to $16,000. A smaller colonial in good shape with a simple color change lands at the bottom. A big one with peeling cedar, a brick front, and a color change from dark to light lands at the top. A house with rot in the trim or a failed previous coat goes past it, because carpentry isn't painting and it bills separately.
Treat that as a planning illustration, not a quote. The only number that counts is the one written after somebody walks your house, measures the walls, and looks at the paint up close. If you want that number from us, the free quote request is the way to start.
What Pushes the Cost to Paint a Colonial in Franklin Lakes Up — or Down
Condition first. A house painted eight years ago with a sound coat underneath is a wash, a scrape of the loose spots, and two coats. A house painted fifteen years ago with peeling on the south face and bare wood showing is a different job — more scraping, more sanding, more spot priming, sometimes a full prime coat before the finish goes on. The paint that's already on the house decides how much prep the new paint needs, and prep is the expensive half.
Color change second. Same color over same color is the cheapest repaint there is. Going from a dark green to a white, or from a stained cedar to a painted finish, adds a coat — sometimes a full prime coat plus two finish coats instead of two finish coats. On a house with 2,400 square feet of wall, one extra coat is real money in labor and material.
Siding material third. Clapboard is straightforward. Cedar shake wants a stain-blocking primer and back-brushing, which is slower. Brick wants more paint per square foot and a masonry primer on the bare spots. Stucco wants an elastomeric or a high-build coating if there are hairline cracks. We wrote about cedar shake in Saddle River recently, and about what a big Bergen County estate exterior needs in Alpine — same county, same weather, same lesson: the surface decides the system, and the system decides the price.
Height and access fourth. Two stories is standard for a colonial, but a three-story rear elevation on a sloped lot, or a garage wing that needs a lift to reach, adds equipment and time. A house you can walk around with a ladder costs less to paint than a house you need a machine to reach.
Timing fifth. Exterior paint wants dry days and temperatures above 35 degrees — both Aura and Duration bottom out around there, and both want four hours before recoat, longer when it's cold. In Bergen County that gives you roughly April through October, and the good weeks in that window book up first. A job squeezed into November costs more in lost days to weather than the same job in June.
What pushes it down? A sound existing coat, a same-color repaint, easy access, and booking early. That's most of it. There's no trick to a cheaper colonial repaint. There's just a house in better shape and a schedule with slack in it.
And the Inside? What a Whole-House Colonial Repaint Runs
Most Franklin Lakes colonials we quote for the exterior also get asked about the inside, usually in the same visit. The center-hall layout means a lot of rooms — four or five bedrooms, a formal living room and dining room, a family room, a kitchen, two or three baths, a two-story foyer with a staircase that needs a tall ladder and a steady hand.
Homewyse's May 2026 calculator puts a full-home interior at $4.79 to $9.04 a square foot of floor, walls and trim included. Walls only run $1.29 to $2.78 a square foot of wall, and ceilings $1.37 to $2.95. Run the full-home rate across a 2,800-square-foot colonial and you get roughly $13,400 to $25,300 — and New Jersey sits toward the high end of that range, same as the exterior. Angi's national figure for walls, trim, and ceilings together is $4.70 a square foot, which lands a house this size around $13,200 at the low end.
The trim is the story inside, same as outside. A colonial's interior trim package — baseboards, crown molding, door casings, wainscoting in the dining room, a staircase with a dozen spindles — is all hand work, and it eats hours. Ceilings in a two-story foyer are the other quiet cost: tall walls, a tall ladder, and cutting in at a height where every wobble shows. For scale, a full two-bedroom repaint in Hoboken runs a fraction of this — different town, different house, different job entirely — but the principle is the same: the trim and the ceilings are where the hours hide.
One thing worth saying plainly: the interior and the exterior are priced on different rulers. The exterior is priced on paintable wall area. The interior is usually priced on floor area, with the walls, ceilings, and trim bundled in. When two quotes for the same house look wildly different, the first thing to check is which ruler each one used. A per-square-foot number means nothing until you know what's in the square foot.
The Paint We'd Put on a House Like This
On a house this size, the paint is maybe a tenth of the invoice, so buying the better gallon is the cheapest insurance in the whole job. The two lines we reach for most on Bergen County exteriors are Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior and Sherwin-Williams Duration, and the choice between them usually comes down to the surface and the color, not the brand. We compared the two lines in detail a while back, and the short version holds: both are top-tier 100-percent acrylics, both cover well, both hold color.
The specs that matter on a colonial: Aura goes on between 35 and 100 degrees, dries to the touch in an hour, and recoats in four. Duration goes down to 35 degrees too, covers 250 to 300 square feet a gallon, and needs four hours before recoat at 45 degrees and up — 24 to 48 hours when it's between 35 and 45. In a New Jersey spring, when the mornings are cold and the afternoons are fine, that recoat window decides whether the crew finishes a face in a day or comes back for it.
Sheen matters more than most people think. Flat or low lustre on the siding hides the waves in old clapboard. Semi-gloss on the trim and the front door takes the weather and wipes clean. Satin on the shutters splits the difference. A colonial with flat siding and glossy trim looks right because the contrast is doing work the color alone can't.
And the primer, since someone always asks: new cedar and bare wood get a stain-blocking primer, always. A gallon of primer is forty dollars. A coat of finish peeling off tannin bleed in two years is a repaint. There's no version of this math where skipping the primer wins.
When to Book It
The painting window in Bergen County runs roughly April through October, with May, June, and September the sweet spot — warm enough for the paint to cure, dry enough that the crew isn't losing days to rain. July and August work fine too, but the heat means earlier starts and more water breaks, and the shade side of the house is where the crew ends up by noon.
The mistake we see every year is the October call. The house needs paint, the owner finally has time to think about it, and the calendar has about three good weeks left. If the weather cooperates, it works. If it doesn't, the job slides to spring, and the house spends a winter with the paint it already has. Book in the spring and you pick your week. Book in October and the weather picks it for you.
If you're selling, the timing flips. A fresh exterior before listing photographs is one of the cheapest curb-appeal moves there is, and the local agents who work Franklin Lakes will tell you the same. Our list of the best realtors for sellers in Hudson and Bergen counties is a good place to start if you don't already have one — and the September median sale of $1,525,000 is a reminder of what's at stake in the photographs.
How to Read a Quote Without Getting Burned
Three quotes, same house, three different numbers. Here's how to sort them.
First, check the prep. The quote should list the wash, the scrape, the sand, the caulk, and the spot prime as separate lines. If it says "prep included" and nothing else, you don't know what prep you're getting, and the painter doesn't either. Prep is 40 to 60 percent of the labor on an exterior. A quote that hides it is a quote that will cut it.
Second, check the coats. Two finish coats on the siding, two on the trim, primer where the wood is bare. One coat is not a repaint; it's a color wash that will show the old color through it by next summer. If a bid is much lower than the others, count the coats first.
Third, check the paint by name. "Premium exterior paint" isn't a product. Benjamin Moore Aura, Sherwin-Williams Duration — a brand and a line, written down. If the paint isn't named, the painter is keeping the option to buy the cheapest gallon on the shelf.
Fourth, check what's not in it. Carpentry, rot repair, and lead-safe work on a pre-1978 house all bill separately, and they should — but they should be named as exclusions, not discovered halfway through the job. Homewyse's own calculator excludes lead testing and remediation, sales tax, and permit fees. A good quote does the same, in writing.
And if you're comparing Bergen County to Manhattan for a sense of scale: a 2026 survey of 32 New York City painting companies put the average full two-bedroom repaint in Manhattan near $8,000, with quotes running from under $4,000 to over $16,000. A Franklin Lakes colonial exterior at $9,000 to $16,000 is a bigger job than a Manhattan two-bedroom — more wall, more trim, more ladder — and the numbers line up once you see it that way.
A colonial in Franklin Lakes is a house worth painting properly. It's a big surface, a lot of trim, and a standard of finish that shows every shortcut. Get three quotes, read the prep lines, and pick the painter who measured the walls instead of guessing from the curb. If you want our number, tell us about the house and we'll come look at it — that's the only way a price on a house like this means anything.