Tenafly's Historic Homes: Getting the Trim Colors Right
Walk the Magnolia Avenue Historic District on a clear November afternoon and you'll see Tenafly historic homes at their best — big Queen Annes with turrets and wraparound porches, Colonials with deep eaves, all of them handsome. And almost all of them painted the same way: white body, white trim, maybe a black door if somebody felt brave. It looks clean. It looks safe. And it's wrong, at least if you care about what these houses actually looked like when they were built.
The original painters in Tenafly didn't do white-on-white. They couldn't have — the paint they had didn't come in a bright, clean white that stayed white, and the fashion of the day ran the other way entirely. A Tenafly Victorian in 1890 wore three colors, sometimes four or five, with the trim doing most of the talking. The white-on-white look is a twentieth-century habit that stuck. Getting the trim right isn't about being fussy. It's the difference between a house that looks like it belongs on its street and one that looks like it got the same treatment as a new build in a subdivision.
Tenafly Historic Homes: Three Districts, One Rulebook
Tenafly is a small borough — about 15,400 people, 15,409 in the 2020 census and an estimated 15,237 as of July 2025 — and it's one of the most expensive towns we work in. The Census Bureau puts the median owner-occupied home value at $1,002,600 and the median household income at $208,200. The town was incorporated in 1894, and a lot of its housing stock predates the First World War. Walk Magnolia Avenue and the property records tell the story house by house: a Queen Anne built in 1888 at 54 Magnolia, once home to publisher Frederic L. Colver, Tenafly's ninth mayor; a 1911 house at 56 Magnolia that sold in April 2026 for $1,900,000; a 1908 house at 76 Magnolia that sold that July for $999,000. These aren't museum pieces. People live in them, sell them, and repaint them — which is exactly where the trim question starts.
Before you buy a single gallon, find out whether your house sits in one of Tenafly's three historic districts — the Palisades, Atwood's Highwood Park, or the Magnolia Avenue Historic District — and whether it's a contributing structure. The borough's own FAQ page is blunt about it: the Zoning Officer can tell you if your home is contributing or non-contributing, and if it's contributing, exterior changes need a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic Preservation Commission. Interiors don't — anything inside that doesn't touch the exterior is clear. But paint on the outside counts as an exterior change.
Here's the part most homeowners miss: the process isn't adversarial. The commission welcomes informal discussion of a project at the earliest stage of planning, and for minor changes the chairperson can issue the certificate immediately if they agree with the Zoning Officer's determination. Bring actual color chips. Show the scheme on the house, not just on a fan deck. The one thing that slows jobs down is a homeowner who already bought fifteen gallons of a color the commission won't approve. Call the Zoning Officer at 201-568-6100, extension 5506, before you call us. It takes ten minutes and it can save you a repaint.
The stakes are real because Tenafly takes this seriously. By 2016, at least 65 private properties in the borough had gained local landmark status, and owners of landmarked homes can't make exterior alterations without commission approval. The town's history runs deep — the Elizabeth Cady Stanton House at 135 Highwood Avenue was built around 1868 and was Stanton's home from 1868 to 1887, the railroad station at the center of town went up in 1874 and ran until 1966, and the Cotswold Mansion on Byrne Lane, built in 1925, was home to bandleader Glenn Miller in the 1940s. If you're selling a Tenafly home rather than repainting to stay, our list of realtors for sellers in Hudson and Bergen counties is a good place to start, and a local agent's Tenafly housing guide lays out the town's neighborhoods and history in one place.
What the Original Painters Actually Did
The best short guide to historic exterior color we've ever found wasn't written by a paint company. It was prepared by John Fiske for the Ipswich Historical Commission in Massachusetts, and it lays out the Victorian rules plainly: paint was used to delineate three visual elements — the body (the big wall surfaces), the trim (the decorative woodwork framing those surfaces), and the sash (the moving parts: doors, windows, shutters). Body, trim, and sash were usually painted in different colors. A three-color scheme was the most common, and later in the period houses often got four or even five.
Two details from that guide change how you look at these houses. First, in the early Victorian period, from 1840 to 1870, trim was never white. It was often a darker shade of the body color — or, if the body was dark, the trim went lighter, and sometimes body, trim, and sash were painted in three increasingly darker shades of the same color. The first color card published in the United States, in 1842, offered three shades of grey and three of fawn, a color they called "drab." Nobody was painting a Queen Anne bright white in 1850 because the paint didn't exist and the taste didn't either.
Second, after 1870, the three-color scheme became the norm: one color for the body, a second for the trim, and the third — always the darkest — for the sash. That darkest color on the window sash is the move most people skip, and it's the one that changes a facade the most. Dark sash turns each window into a clean rectangle and lets the casing read as a frame. Paint the sash the same white as the casing and every window on the house dissolves into a pale smear. We've seen the same three-part rhythm — body, trim, accent — work on the 1860s rowhouses around Van Vorst Park in Jersey City, where our sister site wrote up the colors that belong on those blocks. Tenafly's freestanding Victorians have more surface to work with, but the grammar is the same.
Why does white-on-white fail on these houses? Because the architecture wants contrast to show the woodwork. A Queen Anne has brackets under the eaves, spindlework on the porch, carved bargeboards on the gables, fish-scale shingles on the turret. Paint all of it the same white and it flattens into one pale mass — you paid for the ornament and then hid it. The Victorians understood this. Their colors were muted by modern standards — olives, ochres, warm greys, dusty golds — but they were layered, and the layering is what made the trim read.
Two Palettes Worth Starting From
You don't have to invent a historic scheme from scratch. Both big manufacturers have done the homework, and both palettes are built for exactly this architecture.
Benjamin Moore's Historical Color Collection is the one we reach for first. It's 191 colors drawn from classic North American architecture, and it turned 50 years old in 2026 — it debuted in 1976, alongside the American bicentennial. Nearly every color in the collection is available in exterior products, which matters, because a lot of "historic" palettes only exist for interiors. Their own exterior guidance gives you the grammar in one paragraph: Heritage Red HC-181 and Hawthorne Yellow HC-4 are the classic front-door colors, and Manchester Tan HC-81 and Stonington Gray HC-170 are the can't-miss neutrals. The best sellers read like a Tenafly block on a good day — Revere Pewter HC-172, Kendall Charcoal HC-166, Essex Green HC-188, Hale Navy HC-154 — and Hamilton Blue HC-191 has long been a favorite for trims, shutters, and doors. The full collection runs from HC-1 to HC-191, and because it's curated to coordinate, mixing a body, trim, and accent color from inside it is straightforward.
Sherwin-Williams answers with the America's Heritage Palette, a set of color combinations based on authentic schemes from their respective eras — from the exuberant hues that adorned ornately appointed Victorians to the softer, restrained shades of Craftsman bungalows. Their Victorian Preservation Palette is the one to ask for at the store: Rookwood Dark Red SW 2801, Rookwood Terra Cotta SW 2803, Renwick Rose Beige SW 2804, Rookwood Blue Green SW 2811, Renwick Olive SW 2815, Downing Slate SW 2819, Downing Stone SW 2821. The palette sheet even prints complete schemes — body Rookwood Blue Green, trim Rookwood Terra Cotta, accent Renwick Beige, for one — so you're starting from a combination somebody already tested on a real house.
We've sprayed, brushed, and rolled both brands for years, and we wrote up the honest comparison a while back. For a Tenafly exterior, the brand matters less than the system: pick one manufacturer's palette and stay inside it for the whole scheme, so the undertones agree with each other. Mixing a Benjamin Moore body with a Sherwin-Williams trim is how you end up with a grey that looks green at 4 PM and a trim that looks pink next to it.
Picking Your Three Colors Without Guessing
Here's the method we use on a walkthrough, and it works on a Magnolia Avenue Queen Anne the same way it works on a Colonial in Franklin Lakes.
Start with the body, and make it the least interesting color in the scheme. That's the part people resist. A saturated body color on a house with this much surface area stops being a color and becomes a condition — you notice the paint instead of the bracket work it's supposed to support. Muted olive, warm grey, dusty gold, a range of ochres: these sit back and let the trim do the talking. On a brick-front house the brick itself is often the body color, which means the trim scheme does all the work — a cream cornice against deep-green sash, a black or charcoal door with the brass polished up.
Then the trim, one or two steps away from the body — lighter if the body is dark, darker if the body is light. This is where the house gets its definition: the casings, the corner boards, the fascia, the porch columns. Then the sash and the door, the darkest color in the scheme. Black, deep green, oxblood red, Hale Navy. The door is the one place to be bold. It's a small surface, it's the first thing a visitor touches, and if you hate it in a year, repainting a door is an afternoon.
Three combinations we'd actually put on a Tenafly house tomorrow:
- Warm grey and green: body Stonington Gray HC-170, trim Elmira White HC-84, sash and door Essex Green HC-188. Quiet from the street, sharp up close.
- Tan and red: body Manchester Tan HC-81, trim Elmira White HC-84, door Heritage Red HC-181. The classic, and it photographs beautifully against brick chimneys.
- Sherwin's Victorian set: body Rookwood Blue Green SW 2811, trim Rookwood Terra Cotta SW 2803, accent Renwick Beige SW 2804. Deeper, moodier, and right for a house with a lot of gingerbread to show off.
Two practical notes before you commit. First, test on boards, not on the house, and prop the boards against the trim for a week. Paint looks different at 9 AM and at 4 PM, when the sun rakes sideways across the west-facing trim and shows every lap mark and every undertone you missed at noon. Second, mind the sheen. Traditional practice runs high gloss on the sash, satin on the trim, and flat or low lustre on the body — and that's not a stylistic flourish. The gloss difference is part of how the layers read from the curb, and satin on trim sheds water and wipes clean in a way flat paint never will.
The Prep Nobody Sees (and the Lead Paint Under It)
A trim-heavy Victorian is a prep job with some painting attached. The trim is where paint fails first — caulk dries out at the joints, water gets behind the casing, the sill ends rot, and every layer of old paint adds weight until the whole thing starts to peel in sheets. On a house from 1888 or 1911, we're usually looking at five, six, seven generations of paint on the same board. The prep is scraping the loose stuff, sanding the edges smooth so the new coat doesn't telegraph every ridge, spot-priming the bare wood, and re-caulking the joints that actually move. Skip any of that and the most expensive paint in the store peels off in two winters. The paint's only as good as what's under it, and on old clapboard that's more true than anywhere else.
Then there's the lead. Any house built before 1978 is assumed to carry lead paint, and most Tenafly historic homes were built decades before that. Under the EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting rule, any paid contractor whose work disturbs painted surfaces in a pre-1978 home has to be certified and trained in lead-safe work practices — and the rule kicks in on exteriors once the work disturbs more than 20 square feet of painted surface. Window replacement and demolition of painted surfaces are covered no matter how small the job. That means containment, no open-flame burning, no heat guns at or above 1,100°F, and no high-speed sanding without a HEPA vacuum attachment. If a painter tells you lead isn't an issue on a 1908 house, or offers to just "sand it all off quick," that's your sign to keep looking. We wrote up the full picture — what the law requires and how a legit job gets done safely — in our post on painting over old lead paint in pre-war buildings, and the same rules apply in Tenafly. New Jersey's own lead-safe certificates run three years under P.L. 2024, c.74, which matters if the house is a rental or will be.
Moisture is the other silent killer on these houses. Check the north side, where the sun never quite reaches, and the porch columns, where water sits. Don't paint over damp wood — the paint will look fine for a month and bubble by spring. We check moisture with a meter before we prime, and if a board reads wet, we wait. The same instinct applies inside, by the way: our Manhattan crew wrote up how to paint a pre-war apartment without losing its detail, and the core idea is identical — the original woodwork is the asset, and the paint job should protect it, not bury it.
What Tenafly Historic Homes Cost to Paint
Nobody can price your house from a blog post, and any painter who tries is guessing. But planning ranges help, so here are the honest ones. A MarketMinute cost survey published this fall puts exterior painting at roughly $1.50 to $5.00 per square foot of paintable surface — about $3,000 to $10,000 for a typical 2,000-square-foot home — with labor accounting for 70 to 90 percent of the total. The same survey notes This Old House's range of $2.20 to $4.40 per square foot, putting a two-story, 2,000-square-foot home at $6,900 to $12,700. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a May 2025 median wage of $23.75 an hour for construction and maintenance painters, which is the national number — Bergen County runs higher.
Our own statewide guide puts New Jersey exteriors at $1,900 to $6,900, with two-story homes at $7,000 to $12,000, Northeast labor running 20 to 25 percent above the national average at $60 to $85 an hour, and prep taking 40 to 60 percent of the labor. A Tenafly Victorian lands at the top of those ranges, not the bottom, and the reason is the trim. The body of the house is the cheap part — big flat surfaces, a roller, done. The trim is linear feet of brushwork: casings, brackets, spindles, dentils, all of it by hand, most of it off a ladder. Add lead-safe setup and a Certificate of Appropriateness process that asks you to slow down and get the colors right, and you've got a job that costs more per square foot than a plain Colonial with vinyl siding. That's not a markup. That's the house.
For planning purposes: a 2,000-square-foot home has roughly 1,700 square feet of paintable surface, and at $3 to $5 a square foot that's $5,100 to $8,500 nationally. In Bergen County, with the labor premium and a trim-heavy Victorian that needs real prep, plan $7,000 to $12,000 for a thorough two-story exterior. That's a planning illustration, not a quote — the spread between a house with sound siding and a house with seven layers of peeling paint is thousands of dollars, and nobody knows which one you've got until they're standing on your porch with a scraper in hand. For a sense of what a big Bergen County exterior job actually involves, our write-ups of an Alpine estate exterior and cedar shake in Saddle River walk through the prep cycle on houses this size.
When to Paint It
New Jersey gives you a real exterior season, and it's shorter than people think. We paint Tenafly exteriors from late April through October, when daytime highs are reliably in the 50s and 60s and the wood has had a chance to dry out from winter. November can work on a warm stretch, but the north-facing trim dries slow that time of year, and one cold snap overnight can ruin a coat that looked fine at 3 PM. The practical move is to book the estimate in the winter — that's when you do the color research, talk to the commission, and get on the schedule — and paint in the spring, when the crews have daylight and the paint has time to cure.
If your house is on Magnolia Avenue or anywhere else in one of the three districts, start with the borough, then the color chips, then the painter. The houses on those streets have survived 130 years because somebody cared enough to get the details right. The trim colors are the smallest part of the job and the most visible part of the result. Get them right and the whole street looks better for it.
If you'd like us to walk your house and put together a written estimate — colors, prep, lead-safe setup, and the commission paperwork included — reach out through our homepage and we'll set up a time. We paint all over Bergen County, and Tenafly's old houses are some of our favorite work in the county.